A Guide to Employment Law for SMEs – Conducting Fair and Legal Redundancies

Need an employment contract template? Check out our Free Employment Contract Generator.

Navigating the complexities of employment law represents a formidable challenge for Small and Medium-sized Enterprises (SMEs) in England and Wales, particularly when it comes to the sensitive area of conducting redundancies. The process is fraught with legal pitfalls that can have significant financial and reputational consequences if not handled correctly. Understanding the intricacies of employment law and ensuring compliance is crucial for SMEs to manage redundancies in a fair and legal manner. This comprehensive guide aims to provide SMEs with essential insights into employment law regarding redundancies, covering legal overview, identifying genuine redundancy situations, consultation processes, calculating fair redundancy payments, avoiding unfair dismissal claims, and supporting ex-employees post-redundancy.

Understanding Redundancy: Legal Overview

Redundancy occurs when employers need to reduce their workforce because a job or jobs are no longer needed. In England and Wales, the legal framework governing redundancy is intricate, designed to protect both the employer and employee’s rights. The Employment Rights Act 1996, alongside subsequent amendments and case law, outlines the definition of redundancy, the rights of employees being made redundant, and the responsibilities of employers. To lawfully execute redundancies, employers must ensure that the reason for redundancy is genuine and relates to their business needs.

The redundancy process must be conducted fairly, transparently, and without discrimination. Employers are obligated to consider alternative options to redundancy, such as redeployment within the company. If redundancies are inevitable, the selection criteria should be objective, fair, and applied consistently. Failure to adhere to these principles can lead to claims of unfair dismissal, resulting in potential financial penalties and damage to the company’s reputation.

It is also paramount that employers keep comprehensive records of the entire redundancy process. This documentation can prove invaluable if the redundancy decision is challenged in an employment tribunal. Understanding these legal requirements is the first step for SMEs to navigate the redundancy process successfully.

Identifying a Genuine Redundancy Situation

Identifying a genuine redundancy situation is crucial for ensuring the process is legally compliant. The definition of redundancy under employment law includes business closure (whether that is the closure of the business altogether or just a particular workplace), a diminished need for employees to carry out work of a particular kind, or the decision that the work can be done more efficiently by fewer or different employees.

To establish a genuine redundancy situation, SMEs must demonstrate that the need to make employees redundant is driven by business needs, such as cost reduction, changes in market demand, technological advancements, or reorganization for operational efficiency. It is not sufficient for an employer to label a dismissal as redundancy without substantiating the business rationale behind it.

In determining a genuine redundancy situation, it is advisable for SMEs to have a clear, documented business case that outlines the reasons for the proposed redundancies, how roles are affected, and why these specific roles can no longer be sustained. This documentation can be critical in defending the decision if challenged legally.

Furthermore, employers must be wary of using redundancy as a guise to dismiss troublesome or underperforming employees. Such practices not only undermine the legitimacy of the redundancy process but also leave employers vulnerable to claims of unfair dismissal or discrimination.

Consultation Process: Legal Obligations

A key aspect of managing redundancies lawfully involves conducting a proper consultation process. Legal obligations mandate that employers engage in meaningful consultation with employees who are at risk of redundancy. The consultation aims to discuss the reasons for the redundancy, explore alternative solutions to avoid dismissals, and consider any suggestions employees might have to alleviate the situation.

For redundancies involving 20 or more employees within a 90-day period, employers are required to conduct collective consultations. This involves consulting with trade union representatives or elected employee representatives. The consultation must start at least 30 days before any dismissals take effect (or 45 days if 100 or more redundancies are proposed). For fewer than 20 redundancies, there is no set period for consultation, but it must be undertaken in a meaningful and reasonable manner.

The consultation process is not a mere formality; it must be conducted with a genuine intent to seek alternatives and mitigate the impact of redundancy. Failure to consult appropriately can lead to claims of unfair dismissal and the requirement to pay protective awards.

Documenting the consultation process meticulously, including the reasons for decisions made, alternatives considered, and feedback from employees, is vital. This documentation can provide crucial evidence should the redundancy process be challenged in an employment tribunal.

Calculating Fair Redundancy Payments

Employees with at least two years of service who are made redundant are entitled to statutory redundancy payments, which are calculated based on age, length of service, and weekly pay (up to a statutory maximum). The formula for these calculations is set out in the Employment Rights Act 1996. SMEs must ensure they accurately calculate and provide these payments to eligible employees.

Beyond statutory redundancy payments, some employers may choose to offer enhanced redundancy packages to support their employees further. While not legally required, such packages can help maintain a positive relationship with departing employees and uphold the company’s reputation.

It is important for SMEs to be transparent about how redundancy payments are calculated and to communicate this clearly to the affected employees. Misunderstandings or discrepancies in redundancy payments can lead to disputes and potential legal challenges.

Ensuring accurate record-keeping and documentation throughout the calculation process can safeguard against claims of unfair or incorrect payment. Employers should consider seeking legal advice or using redundancy payment calculators provided by reputable sources to ensure compliance.

Avoiding Unfair Dismissal Claims

To avoid unfair dismissal claims, SMEs must ensure that the redundancy process is conducted fairly and transparently, with a genuine business reason behind it. The selection criteria for redundancy should be objective, non-discriminatory, and consistently applied. Employers must also consider any alternative employment within the company and offer suitable vacancies to those at risk of redundancy.

Challenging an unfair dismissal claim can be costly and time-consuming. It can also damage the company’s reputation. Providing clear communication throughout the redundancy process, offering support to affected employees, and ensuring that all legal obligations are met can help mitigate the risk of such claims.

Training managers and HR professionals on how to handle redundancies sensitively and in accordance with the law is also crucial. This not only helps in preventing legal challenges but also in preserving the morale of remaining employees.

Employers who are unsure about any aspect of the redundancy process should seek legal advice. This can provide reassurance that the process is being handled correctly and help prevent potential legal pitfalls.

Post-Redundancy: Supporting Ex-Employees

Supporting employees post-redundancy is an important aspect of the redundancy process that can sometimes be overlooked. Offering outplacement support, such as career coaching or resume writing services, can assist ex-employees in finding new employment and demonstrate that the employer is taking a responsible and caring approach to the redundancy.

Communicating available support options clearly to affected employees and providing references can also aid them in their job search. Such measures not only benefit the ex-employees but can also positively impact the company’s reputation and the morale of remaining staff.

SMEs should consider the long-term impact of how redundancies are handled and strive to maintain a positive relationship with all employees, both current and former. This approach can help build a resilient and supportive company culture.


Conducting fair and legal redundancies requires a thorough understanding of employment law, meticulous planning, and a compassionate approach towards affected employees. SMEs in England and Wales face the challenge of balancing legal obligations with the need to make difficult business decisions. By following the guidelines outlined in this comprehensive guide, SMEs can navigate the redundancy process with greater confidence and integrity.

As complex as employment law can be, especially in times of change, considering the support of expert legal advice can be invaluable. Not only does it provide peace of mind, but it also ensures that your business is fully compliant with the law, minimizing the risk of costly legal disputes. While this guide serves as a starting point, the nuances of individual situations may require professional consultation. For those looking to safeguard their business further and navigate the redundancy process with expert care, consider exploring the legal services available through this site.

Scroll to Top